{"id":"linear-baseline","type":"method","name_en":"Simple linear baseline","name_zh":"简单线性基线","aliases":["linear baseline","baseline gap"],"description":{"en":"Simple linear models used as reference points for perturbation prediction. Ahlmann-Eltze et al. report that deep-learning gene perturbation prediction does not yet outperform them, and later preprints report that the baseline gap persists.","zh":"用作扰动预测参照的简单线性模型。Ahlmann-Eltze 等报告深度学习基因扰动预测尚未超越它们，后续预印本报告该基线差距仍然存在。"},"externalIds":{},"graphNames":["linear baseline"],"mentions":{"items":["VC0048","VC0054","VC0110"],"topics":["cell-state-mes-like","model-virtual-cell","validation-benchmarks"]},"evidenceRefs":["VC0048","VC0054","VC0053"],"reviewStatus":"draft","version":"0.1.0","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/entities/linear-baseline/","page_url_zh":"https://gliostate.com/zh/entities/linear-baseline/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/entities/linear-baseline.json","external_links":[],"source_file":"https://gliostate.com/data/entities/linear-baseline.json","evidence_items":[{"id":"VC0048","title":"Deep-learning-based gene perturbation effect prediction does not yet outperform simple linear baselines.","year":"2025","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0048/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0048.json"},{"id":"VC0054","title":"An Empirical Comparison of Virtual Cell Models: Perturbation Prediction, Representation, and the Baseline Gap","year":"2026","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0054/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0054.json"},{"id":"VC0053","title":"Signal, Bounds, and Baselines: Principles for Evaluating Virtual Cell Perturbation Models","year":"2026","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0053/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0053.json"}],"mentioned_in_items":[{"id":"VC0048","title":"Deep-learning-based gene perturbation effect prediction does not yet outperform simple linear baselines.","year":"2025","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0048/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0048.json"},{"id":"VC0054","title":"An Empirical Comparison of Virtual Cell Models: Perturbation Prediction, Representation, and the Baseline Gap","year":"2026","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0054/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0054.json"},{"id":"VC0110","title":"Causal Models Need Causal Data - Xaira's X-Cell (podcast)","year":"2026","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0110/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0110.json"}],"mentioned_in_topics":[{"id":"cell-state-mes-like","title_en":"Mesenchymal-like (MES-like) glioblastoma cell state","title_zh":"胶质母细胞瘤间充质样（MES 样）细胞状态","url":"https://gliostate.com/cell-states/mesenchymal-like/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/topics/cell-state-mes-like.json"},{"id":"model-virtual-cell","title_en":"AI virtual cell models","title_zh":"AI 虚拟细胞模型","url":"https://gliostate.com/models/virtual-cell/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/topics/model-virtual-cell.json"},{"id":"validation-benchmarks","title_en":"Validating virtual cells: benchmarks, baselines and critiques","title_zh":"虚拟细胞的验证：基准、基线与批评","url":"https://gliostate.com/validation/benchmarks-and-baselines/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/topics/validation-benchmarks.json"}],"relations":[{"subject":"perturbation-prediction","subject_name_en":"Perturbation response prediction","subject_name_zh":"扰动反应预测","predicate":"benchmarked_on","object":"linear-baseline","object_name_en":"Simple linear baseline","object_name_zh":"简单线性基线","confidence":"high","evidence":[{"id":"VC0048","role":"benchmark","title":"Deep-learning-based gene perturbation effect prediction does not yet outperform simple linear baselines.","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0048/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0048.json"},{"id":"VC0049","role":"benchmark","title":"Benchmarking foundation cell models for post-perturbation RNA-seq prediction.","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0049/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0049.json"}],"note":{"en":"Deep models do not yet reliably outperform simple linear baselines.","zh":"深度模型尚不能稳定超越简单线性基线。"},"sources":[{"kind":"topic","id":"validation-benchmarks","url":"https://gliostate.com/validation/benchmarks-and-baselines/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/topics/validation-benchmarks.json"}]},{"subject":"x-cell","subject_name_en":"X-Cell (Xaira)","subject_name_zh":"X-Cell（Xaira）","predicate":"benchmarked_on","object":"linear-baseline","object_name_en":"Simple linear baseline","object_name_zh":"简单线性基线","confidence":"low","evidence":[{"id":"VC0033","role":"supports","title":"X-Cell: Scaling Causal Perturbation Prediction Across Diverse Cellular Contexts via Diffusion Language Models","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0033/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0033.json"},{"id":"VC0048","role":"contradicts","title":"Deep-learning-based gene perturbation effect prediction does not yet outperform simple linear baselines.","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/library/VC0048/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/items/VC0048.json"}],"note":{"en":"X-Cell (preprint, not peer reviewed) claims to surpass linear baselines, whereas the Nature Methods benchmark found earlier deep models did not; VC0048 does not test X-Cell, so the “contradicts” role is a tension, not a refutation. Needs review.","zh":"X-Cell（预印本，未经同行评审）声称超越线性基线，而 Nature Methods 基准发现此前的深度模型未能做到；VC0048 并未测试 X-Cell，“反驳”仅表示存在张力而非证伪。需复核。"},"sources":[{"kind":"topic","id":"model-virtual-cell","url":"https://gliostate.com/models/virtual-cell/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/topics/model-virtual-cell.json"},{"kind":"topic","id":"validation-benchmarks","url":"https://gliostate.com/validation/benchmarks-and-baselines/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/topics/validation-benchmarks.json"}]}],"related_entities":[{"id":"perturbation-prediction","type":"method","name_en":"Perturbation response prediction","name_zh":"扰动反应预测","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/entities/perturbation-prediction/","page_url_zh":"https://gliostate.com/zh/entities/perturbation-prediction/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/entities/perturbation-prediction.json","via":"relation"},{"id":"x-cell","type":"model","name_en":"X-Cell (Xaira)","name_zh":"X-Cell（Xaira）","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/entities/x-cell/","page_url_zh":"https://gliostate.com/zh/entities/x-cell/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/entities/x-cell.json","via":"relation"},{"id":"foundation-model","type":"method","name_en":"Single-cell foundation model","name_zh":"单细胞基础模型","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/entities/foundation-model/","page_url_zh":"https://gliostate.com/zh/entities/foundation-model/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/entities/foundation-model.json","via":"co-mention"},{"id":"glioblastoma","type":"disease","name_en":"Glioblastoma (GBM)","name_zh":"胶质母细胞瘤（GBM）","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/entities/glioblastoma/","page_url_zh":"https://gliostate.com/zh/entities/glioblastoma/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/entities/glioblastoma.json","via":"co-mention"},{"id":"scfocal","type":"model","name_en":"scFOCAL / ISOSCELES","name_zh":"scFOCAL / ISOSCELES","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/entities/scfocal/","page_url_zh":"https://gliostate.com/zh/entities/scfocal/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/entities/scfocal.json","via":"co-mention"},{"id":"state","type":"model","name_en":"State (Arc Institute)","name_zh":"State（Arc 研究所）","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/entities/state/","page_url_zh":"https://gliostate.com/zh/entities/state/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/entities/state.json","via":"co-mention"},{"id":"systematic-variation","type":"method","name_en":"Systematic variation (evaluation concept)","name_zh":"系统性差异（评估概念）","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/entities/systematic-variation/","page_url_zh":"https://gliostate.com/zh/entities/systematic-variation/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/entities/systematic-variation.json","via":"co-mention"},{"id":"zero-shot-evaluation","type":"method","name_en":"Zero-shot evaluation","name_zh":"零样本评估","page_url":"https://gliostate.com/entities/zero-shot-evaluation/","page_url_zh":"https://gliostate.com/zh/entities/zero-shot-evaluation/","api_url":"https://gliostate.com/api/entities/zero-shot-evaluation.json","via":"co-mention"}]}